Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Our Flavors

Penny Lick’s Flavors


PLEASE NOTE: Due to COVID-19 we are only selling pints and cups, fudgesicles, and push pops at this time. We are also taking ice cream cake orders!

Pints $9 

For curbside pick up and delivery (pints only), please order here

Kids Scoop | Single Scoop | Double Scoop | Triple Scoop | Milkshake | Pints

Want to place a custom cake order? Click here.

Looking to place a large order? 

Call us today! 914.525.1580 (custom requires one week notice)