Our Flavors
Penny Lick’s Flavors
ALWAYS PEANUT AND TREE NUT FREE!
Swing by the store to pick up cups, cones, milkshake, and pints of your favorite flavors.
For curbside pick up and delivery of pints and hot fudge (only), please place your order here! We will follow up with an invoice when we receive your order.
Want to place a custom cake order? https://penny-lick-ice-cream-company.square.site
To join our Ice Cream Club, pick up our Everything But the Scoop! Party Pack (feeds 15), or order a 3-pint pack, visit our SHOP page.
-
Vanilla Bean
There's nothing boring about a great vanilla. (GF)
-
Milk Chocolate
Like a great chocolate bar! (GF)
-
Fresh Mint Chip
Not green, doesn't taste like toothpaste. ;) (GF)
-
Chocolate Malt
A malted chocolate ice cream with crushed malted milk balls. You know, those candies you traded away after Halloween every year. (Contains Gluten)
-
White Bourbon Caramel
White chocolate ice cream with a burnt butter bourbon caramel swirl. (GF)
-
Blueberry Jam
Very blue, very blueberry, made with these teeny tiny wild blueberries from Maine we love. (GF)
-
Earl Grey
A cuppa the Earl with milk, in ice cream form! (GF)
-
Bubble Gum
A special at the moment, tastes exactly like a Bazooka Joe (but, obviously, better) (GF)
-
Creamsicle
Oranges and vanilla cream - a current special and new fan favorite! (GF)
-
Cookies & Cream
Cookies, cream, you know the drill. (Contains Gluten)
-
Lemon Bar
Lemon custard ice cream with crushed vanilla cookies. An inspiration from the food editor of the Journal News! (Contains Gluten)
-
Aloha Coffee
Our classic coffee ice cream, with beans from the Aloha state (GF)
-
Honeycomb
A sweet vanilla ice cream with a honeycomb caramel sponge candy. A nostalgia favorite! (GF)
-
Strawberry
Strawberry is officially back on the menu! It's seasonal, so get it while it's good! (GF)
-
Peppermint Stick
Peppermint candy cane ice cream. It's seasonal, so get it while it lasts! (GF)
-
Dark Chocolate Coconut
Our best seller is also vegan! So rich you have to taste it to believe it! (GF)
vegan
-
Mango Sorbet
Mangoes, lemons and limes in a perfect refreshing scoop! (GF)
vegan
-
Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet
Strawberries and tart lemons in this vegan seasonal favorite! (GF)
vegan
-
Raspberry Lime Sorbet
Tart raspberries and lime, our best selling sorbet (GF)
vegan