580 Warburton Avenue, Hastings on Hudson, NY 10706 914-525-1580
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Our Flavors

different color ice cream on cups and gift cards on the table

Penny Lick’s Flavors

ALWAYS PEANUT AND TREE NUT FREE!

Swing by the store to pick up cups, cones, milkshake, and pints of your favorite flavors.

For curbside pick up and delivery of pints and hot fudge (only), please place your order here! We will follow up with an invoice when we receive your order.

Want to place a custom cake order? https://penny-lick-ice-cream-company.square.site

To join our Ice Cream Club, pick up our Everything But the Scoop! Party Pack (feeds 15), or order a 3-pint pack, visit our SHOP page.

  • Vanilla Bean

    There's nothing boring about a great vanilla. (GF)

  • Milk Chocolate

    Like a great chocolate bar! (GF)

  • Maple Salted Caramel

    Regional maple ice cream with flecks of salty caramel. (GF)

  • Dark Chocolate Coconut Sorbet

    Nearly black in color and very rich in flavor. Made with dark chocolate, coconut milk, and Onyx cocoa. (Vegan) (GF)

    vegan

  • Earl Grey

    A lovely cuppa the Earl with bergamot and milk. (GF)

  • Rum Raisin

    Warning: we like our rum. Strong. (GF)

  • Chocolate Malt

    A malted chocolate ice cream with crushed malted milk balls. You know, those candies you traded away after Halloween every year. (contains gluten)

  • Lavender Truffle

    A floral, lavender ice cream with chunks of bittersweet chocolate truffles. (GF)

  • Fresh Mint Chip

    Our mint chip isn't green, but it is delicious! (GF)

  • Lemon Bar

    A sunny lemon ice cream with vanilla cookie wafer crust throughout. Inspired by Jeanne Muchnick, formerly of Lohud Food! (contains gluten)

  • Strawberry

    Strawberries are back in season! (GF)

  • Cookies & Cream

    Cookies, cream, you know the drill. (Contains Gluten)

  • Grape Nut

    Malted cereal milk ice cream with candied Grape Nut cereal. A New England and Caribbean favorite! (contains gluten)

  • Honey Graham

    Honey ice cream with a hint of cookie butter and baking spices. (contains gluten)

  • Aloha Coffee

    Our take on a classic coffee ice cream, but a bit stronger. (GF)

  • Raspberry Chip

    Slightly tart raspberry ice cream with bittersweet chocolate flakes. (GF)

  • Mango Sorbet

    Juicy mangoes with lemon and lime. (Vegan) (GF)

    vegan

  • Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet

    Bright in color and flavor! (Vegan) (GF)

    vegan

  • White Bourbon Caramel

    A white chocolate ice cream with a bourbon infused caramel swirl. You're welcome. (GF)

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!